I'm Not a Tiger Mom! Grrrr.....

workmom blogs
RSS feed icon Browse the topics @home and @work. Engage with leading bloggers who offer advice on family and career as well as share stories about our rich workmom experience. Share your comments.

engage!

Not a mom blogger?

browse by

I'm Not a Tiger Mom! Grrrr.....

Posted on February 02, 2012
I'm Not a Tiger Mom! Grrrr.....

That was not my response today when someone asked if I was a Tiger Mom.  My immediate response was to say, “No, I’m not a Tiger Mom.” After the conversation, I researched what it meant to be a Tiger Mom. Apparently, I’m behind the times and while I’m a voracious reader, I have not read Amy Chua’s book Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother, in which she describes how Chinese parents are better at raising successful children than Western parents are.

First, while I am Asian, I’m not Chinese. I’m Vietnamese. Whew! Just needed to make that clear on the front end.  Second, I’m not even going to sit here and argue whether the premise of her book is true-whether Asian parents are better parents. (I’m not going to enter that discussion until I’ve read the book.)

The question about whether I’m a Tiger Mom arose because someone at work found out that my daughter is in a gifted program at school.  Yes, she’s five, and she has been part of the program since she was four.  I understand how that can sound a bit suspicious. I’ve heard it all. “Why don’t you let your daughter be a kid?” “Can you really determine whether she’s gifted at age four?” “Don’t you think that’s a bit elitist?” So on and so on.

Yes, we filled out a lot of paperwork and received feedback from teachers and parents. Yes, she was assessed by a child psychologist, and the determination was made that she qualified for the program and had some gifts in the area of linguistics. Yes, she attends the gifted program twice a week with first and second graders that have also qualified for the gifted program.

Why does that make me a “Tiger Mom?” I didn’t push my daughter to do anything. My husband and I explained the process and what it meant to attend these different classes, and she made a choice to go.  She can choose to opt out at any time. I recognize that people don’t think a five-year-old is capable of making that choice, but she can.

Do I want her to excel in academics? Absolutely.  There’s no question that I highly value education. I’d be a professional student if I could, but I don’t force her to focus on academics at home to the exclusion of other experiences in life. She has sleepovers and other extracurricular activities-activities she chooses. I don’t force her to play the piano or violin as Amy Chua describes as the only music lessons permitted for her children.  But the reality for my daughter is that while she adores playing with the kids in her kindergarten class, her mind is capable and hungers to learn more, know more, understand more. I love when she comes home and tells me she’s learning deductive reasoning and research techniques.  I love that she struggles with the challenging work at time. I’d take that over her three-year old self that used to hate going to daycare because she was bored out of her mind!

I doubt my co-worker meant any offense.  She probably was just seeking to understand.  I’d rather she have asked me than to continue to think I am a Tiger Mom who pushes my child to succeed at the cost of her self-worth.

I know I lost points, though, when she asked whether I’ve ever played any instruments.

Ummm…yes, yes I have. I played…er…the piano and…er…the…ummm…violin.

Hey, I said I wasn’t a Tiger Mom.  I never said I didn’t have one…

comments (3)

It’s difficult to find

facecom's picture
by facecom on May 02, 2013
It’s difficult to find educated people on this topic, however, you seem like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks by berita-id

It takes many remarkable men

teacherrunnermom's picture
by teacherrunnermom on February 03, 2012

It takes many remarkable men and women to raise children of any race, Black, White, Asian, Martian.  Back when my dad was an unpolitically correct teacher he used to ask the kids in his math classes who was going to get an "A". The kids always picked out the one or two Asian kids, and my dad would tell them all that they could do the math no matter what. Over the years he had students of all races go on to pursue math degrees at some of our nation's best colleges.

I plan on reading the book

TheLearningMom's picture
by TheLearningMom on February 03, 2012

I plan on reading the book this weekend, but as I read more reviews about it, I came to the conclusion that I fell prey to the negative criticism of the book as a dissertation on her superior parenting style, but as learned, her book is intended to be more of a memoir about how she raised her children with success and mistakes along the way.  I'm intrigued. Maybe I'll find out that I'm more of a "Tiger Mom" than I thought.  Thanks for reading the blog and commenting.

Your Comment
All submitted comments are subject to the license terms set forth in our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use