Lighten Our Plates, Or Lift Heavier Weights?

workmom blogs
RSS feed icon Browse the topics @home and @work. Engage with leading bloggers who offer advice on family and career as well as share stories about our rich workmom experience. Share your comments.

engage!

Not a mom blogger?

browse by

Lighten Our Plates, Or Lift Heavier Weights?

Posted on May 06, 2012

I have been thinking about how the calories in, calories burned model should be so straightforward, but it really isn’t.  Are some women’s magazines giving advice to strong, healthy women to eat 1500 calories per day?   I understand that women with certain body types could maintain their health on 1500 calories per day. A five-foot ten fashion model who generally weighs about the same amount as I do, between 115lbs and 120lbs could probably maintain this weight range by consuming about 1500 calories per day.  I am half a foot or so shorter than your average fashion model, and possess thick, muscular arms and legs thanks to years of endurance sports and weight lifting.  My waist size may be in the same range or even several inches smaller than the fashion models, because remember, I am carrying my weight in my arms and legs, not my in my breasts and tummy.  According to the BMI charts, the healthy weight range for someone who possesses my average height can weigh as few as 108lbs and still be considered healthy.  I would have to weigh as little as 107lbs to be considered underweight, even though before reaching this low weight, my hormone levels would be insufficient to maintain menstruation.  My body fat stores important hormones that help maintain my reproductive and general health. Muscle is an extremely active tissue, and much heavier than fat. Your bones have to work much harder to hold up heavy muscles, which is actually wonderful because this prevents arthritis and other diseases associated with weakening bones. When the numbers on the scale drop for me, I know that I am reducing my essential body fat and losing muscle tone.  I will be weaker and slower when I fall to the lowest possible healthy weight for my height.  Being at the lowest possible healthy weight for ones height is not a positive goal for athletes or mothers.  For models, it might not be so healthy to weigh so little either, but modeling is usually not a career for more than a few years. As mothers, we need to consider our activity level before making a significant calorie reduction. I know that I am constantly burning through the calories that I consume before, during and after work. Please consider lifting heavier dumbbells before lightening your plates! Your bones and your children will thank you for this.

comments (3)

I agree that being thin

fredrodriguez55's picture
by fredrodriguez55 on November 05, 2012
I agree that being thin doesn't necessarily mean being healthy. Obtaining an ideal weight through diet and obtaining it through exercising have different outcomes altogether. Exercise not only enables us to achieve our ideal weight but it also keeps our body fit and healthy and away from illnesses. It also builds up our stamina and boosts our immune systems. There are so many benefits that we can reap through exercising whereas dieting (or eating less daily) only allows us to reach our ideal weight and maintain being slim but does not provide us with the other benefits. http://www.lift-all.com

Thanks for reading! I am

teacherrunnermom's picture
by teacherrunnermom on May 09, 2012

Thanks for reading! I am hoping to inspire moms to take care of themselves and not worry so much about getting to a low number on the scale.

Amanda, this is great

TheLearningMom's picture
by TheLearningMom on May 07, 2012

Amanda, this is great information! I must admit that I am less intentional about my physical health, especially regarding what I eat and exercise.  I am one of those who hears "1500" calories as the ideal intake and use it as a gauge without considering my height or metabolism.

Your Comment
All submitted comments are subject to the license terms set forth in our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use